December 2024
Vaughan Henkel
Head of Securities Solutions, PSG Wealth
Counter | Share price | Intrinsic value | Upside/downside |
NPN | R4 412 | R3 823 | -15% |
PRX | R765 | R737 | -4% |
As at 3 December 2024
In our last report on Naspers and Prosus (in Sep 2024), we discussed the management changes and Tencent’s 2Q24 results, since then, the following events have taken place:
• Naspers and Prosus released half-year results for FY2025.
• Trip.com has been disposed of and Swiggy Limited IPO’d in India, valuing it at $11.3bn at the time of listing.
• Prosus 1st half results had the following highlights:
o Operations delivered top line growth of 26%.
o Adjusted EBIT came in at $60m, turning positive for the first time after reporting a loss of $110m in the first half of 2024.
o Profitability was driven by Classifieds and Food Delivery with EBIT figures of $133m and $94m respectively.
o Core headline earnings increased 76% to $3.5bn
We have updated our valuation to account for the continued share repurchases (repurchase history in Appendix) and changes in market value of listed assets. We have made adjustments to the position of Trip.com and the Swiggy Limited listing. Our intrinsic values remain relatively unchanged (previously NPN: R3 840 and PRX: R740).
Naspers and Prosus shares trade at meaningful discounts to NAV. Management continues to address the closing of the discount which could unlock value for shareholders. However, Naspers and Prosus remain significantly exposed to Tencent which comes with substantial risks. Our view on Tencent, the primary driver of Naspers and Prosus shares and the largest component of NAV, remains cautious especially given the unpredictable and significant influence of the Chinese government.
Table 1: 1H25 Results summary
Sep-2024 (previous report) | Dec-2024 (current report) | Comment | |
NPN discount to NAV | 38% | 35% | Slightly lower |
NPN performance since last report | 13% | 5% | Outperform Tencent |
NPN intrinsic value | 3840 | 3823 | Flat |
NPN recommendation | Hold | Hold | Unchanged |
PRX discount to NAV | 34% | 32% | Slightly narrower |
PRX performance since last report | 14% | 2% | Outperform Tencent |
PRX intrinsic value | 740 | 737 | Flat |
PRX recommendation | Hold | Hold | Unchanged |
Tencent rand performance | 9% | -4.4% | - |
Source: Company financials
Table 6: Valuation multiples
Source: FactSet